Home / Ahmadiyya Beliefs / Question yourself!

Question yourself!

Ahmadis should realize that around the 100 years period of Mirza Ghulam Ahmad there were 4 claimants of prophethood from Ummah, and their off-shoots are running as successfully as Ahmadiyyah.

Baha’u’llah: (Claimed to be Mahdi and manifestation of God on earth)(Died in prison)

http://www.bahai.org/
Born: 12 November, 1817 – Tehran
Died: 1892

 

Mirza Ghulam Ahmad Qadiani: (Claimant of being Isa, Mahdi, Messiah, Krishna, Moses, Muhammad, Adam etc)(Died of “wabaai haiza”)
Born: Feb 13, 1835 – India
Died: May 26. 1908

 

Rashid Khalifa: (Denier of Ahadith, claimant of being a prophet and present the same verse from Qur’an as Ahmadis do.) (killed to death with a knife)

Known by the name of “Submitters”.
Born     November 19, 1935(1935-11-19),Egypt
Died     January 31, 1990(1990-01-31) (aged 54)
Nationality     Egyptian-American

 

Riaz Ahmad Gohar Shahi (Claimed to be Promised Messiah, Kalki Autar and Mahdi)(disappeared)

http://www.goharshahi.com/

Born 25 November 1941
Dhok-Ghohar Shah – Rawalpindi

Even now, people have claimed prophethood and the new prophet claimant Zahid Khan have actually met Mirza Ghulam Ahmad in heaven , according to him. http://www.khanverlag.de/shop/page/?sessid=0uGpiu4MHXSH5PZJ2hnNKUwOPGx5aaJ2QuVn0zzpn7Qba1zHNAOOEjzSXZGQKvUs&shop_param=

 

Last but not the least, even within Ahmadiyyat there are further divisions such as:

Lahore Group http://www.www.aaiil.org
Janba Group http://www.alghulam.com/
Haqiqi Group http://al-ahmadiyyat.com/official/
Green Ahmadiyyat http://greenahmadiyyat.org/

After reading all this, all of you Ahmadis should be asking yourself one question very sincerely, that are you following the right person? Ahmadiyyah does have the belief of more prophets to come, are you going to believe in any of the above mentioned prophets, some of them came after Mirza Sahib? If Your answer is No, then why only Mirza Ghulam Ahmad? What’s your criteria of judging a True and a False prophet? If it’s the size of jama’at and more followers every years then some of them are really competing Ahmadiyyah in that field. But is that the only criteria?

I hope you people will be asking yourselves all these questions, inshaAllah we will all find the right answer. As-sawaal nisful ‘ilm, every question is the half answer.

 

Rate this post

MORE ON AHMEDI.ORG

The following two tabs change content below.
Profile photo of Yousaf Ahmed

Yousaf Ahmed

Check Also

Express tribune on indian pay roll

Is “The Express Tribune” is an Ahmadiyya Media ??

Express Tribune on Indian Payroll. Yesterday, Indian PM Modi tried to divert attention from Kashmir …

20 Comments on "Question yourself!"

Notify of
avatar
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Nasrullah
Guest
Yousaf Ahmed
well, that’s the funny part. Mirza Sahib never provided any references so I don’t blame you Nasrullah.

Mirza Ghulam Ahmed in Chashma-e-Masih, Vol.20, Pg.336 (margin) accepts that {“whatever I have said against the dignity of Isa AS is the reply of allegations and they are actually the words of “JEWS” that I have copied.}
will you explain to me that from this statement what are you trying to prove?
i did not understand your point because this statement is actually supporting my argument that these are not Ahmadiyya beliefs.

Mashood
Guest
Mr. A K Shaikh you have said that all the claimants of Prophethood have their followers today but can you answer my Question that why all the supporters of KHATM E NABUWAT just scold Jamat Ahmadiyya, and it will increase your knowledge that the AALMI MAJLIS KHATM E NABUWAT was formed by all these Mullahs just to OPPOSE JAMAT E AHMADIYYA…… I think if you are a thought full person then you can answer my question…..
Peace
Guest
I would like to ask you the same question. Why is the so called jamat Ahmadiyya only after Muslims?

Do you not see the parallels? You should have thought about this before asking the childish question.

Rationalist
Guest
Mashood

Let me try……KTM Nubuwwa started in the Punjab as a reactionary movement to educate the masses about Ahmadiyyat. Muslims were trying to save people from joining a cult….

Why do you object to that? Ahmadis support something called Humanity First….KTM NUbuwwa is also trying to educate the masses about Ahmadiya and possibly save them from a life of everlasting priase and worship of the Mirza fmaily.

Peace
Guest
,
the teachings of Ahmadiyyat about Isa a.s. you quoted are not at all the teachings of Ahmadiyyat except “Survived from cross, migrated to Kashmir and buried in India”

What is your proof that Hazrat Isa a.s is buried in Kashmir………………would you accept that Ahmadiyyat is fraud if he is not there………….???????????????

Nasrullah
Guest
Ahmadiyyat is the true Islam and based on the teachings of QURAN.

(What is your proof that Hazrat Isa a.s is buried in Kashmir)
for this you have to read Masih Hindustan Main. written by Hazrat Mirza Sahib.

would you accept that Ahmadiyyat is fraud if he is not there………….???????????????
what a childish question, the book i mentioned above is written for the purpose of collecting historical facts about Hazrat Isa a.s.
ahmadiyyat is not based on that book. do you think that Ahmadiyyat is originated after that book?

Peace
Guest
Nasrullah, for your information there are knowledgeable persons who base on historical evidence that grave off Hazrat Isa a.s is not in Kashmir.

So I ask you again is claim of MGA authenti0?

Answer is No. It is just his opinion and not fact so please avoid confusing others based on his opinion without solid proof. Before Kashmir MGA gave two other locations as the grave. If MGA would be alive today he will probably give another location after Kashmir. That’s how big of a Liar MGA was.

Rationalist
Guest
Peace

The “Yus Asaph” theory is a total sham.

Even Lahoris have began to doubt it.

Nasrullah
Guest
Nasrullah, for your information there are knowledgeable persons who base on historical evidence that grave off Hazrat Isa a.s is not in Kashmir.
thanks for providing this information but would you give the names of these Knowledgeable persons?
and also tell me do you agree with the theory they presented?
Rationalist
Guest
Nasrullah

1. Funny thing is..MGA couldnt even finish writing that book in his lifetime. It was published in 1908 after MGA died….

2. The Lahoris have already began to doubt the “Yus Asaf” theory. Its pretty much stupid. MGA stole the ideas of Nicholas Notovitch, then put a twist on them….

Let it go
Guest
Islam is a true religion. Isa (Jesus) a.s according to Islam: 1. Was born to Mariam a.s without a father 2. Spoke while He was still a baby 3. Performed miracles by permission of Allah s.w.t. 4. Was never crucified or killed. Allah s.w.t. raised him up to himself. 5. Isa a.s. will return to Earth as a major sign of the hour “BEHOLD! THE ANGELS SAID: “O MARY! GOD HATH CHOSEN THEE AND PURIFIED THEE- CHOSEN THEE ABOVE THE WOMEN OF ALL NATIONS.” HOLY QURAN 3:42 Behold! the angels said: “O Mary! Allah giveth thee glad tidings of a… Read more »
Nasrullah
Guest
Lanat-ullah-e alal kazibeen. the teachings of Ahmadiyyat about Isa a.s. you quoted are not at all the teachings of Ahmadiyyat except “Survived from cross, migrated to Kashmir and buried in India” also you yourself proving your statement logically not possible as if Hazrat Mirza Ghulam Ahmed A.S claimed to be Isa A.S. then how could he insult Him as insulting Isa A.S means Insulting himself. as far as the other points, which you described as the teachings of Ahmadiyyat are concern, they are written in Hazrat Mirza Sahib’s different books but not as his beliefs but as christian beliefs about… Read more »
Rationalist
Guest
Nasrullah

Im sure MGA cursed himself from time to time…he pretty much cursed everyone else.

Let it go
Guest
@Nasrullah You yourself said “Lanat-ullah-e alal kazibeen” and still lying to the teeth. We have no hatred to Ahmadiyyat just trying to open your eyes to hatred and lies of this so called ‘promised messiah Mirza Ghulam’ who did not even spare the mighty messengers of GOD like Jesus a.s. You are also lying by saying, “they are written in Hazrat Mirza Sahib’s different books but not as his beliefs but as christian beliefs about Isa A.S. with reference to bible.” Can you provide any bible which says such vulgar things about Hazrat Isa a.s as Mirza has falsely accused… Read more »
Nasrullah
Guest
let it go

your attitude shows that you have no proof of your accusations as you deliberately ignoring my comments and keep asking me to provide proof of my statement.
just prove your accusation and then ask me to prove my statement.

Nasrullah
Guest
(Admit your guilt and learn the truth so that you are on the right path rather than accusing others without any proof.)
i think you have not read my comments or else you failed to understand my point.
the statements you claimed to be the teachings of ahmadiyyat about Isa a.s are not the teachings of Ahmadiyyat.
you accused Ahmadiyyat without any proof.
it is your duty to provide the proof of your allegations.
may Allah guide to the right path.
Nasrullah
Guest
Yousaf Ahmed

a very logical proof is that the statements of mirza sahib are not denied by christans to whom he addressed.
and i will surely provide you the references if you post the original statements of Hazrat mirza sahib with reference.

Let it go
Guest
Nasrullah,
“they are written in Hazrat Mirza Sahib’s different books but not as his beliefs but as christian beliefs about Isa A.S. with reference to bible.”

If the above statement of yours is true then provide proof of your claim?
If not this applies to you “Lanat-ullah-e alal kazibeen”

wpDiscuz
Urdu Website